ScotWars - Scottish Military History and Re-enactment
Major James Lothian
A short history of a Scots professional soldier in Cheshire

Jan 1643

Having come from London, Sir William Brereton of Handforth, MP for Cheshire rode down from the Pennines into Congleton on the evening of 27th Jan 1643. He had with him his own troop of horse and 3 companies of dragoon’s. One of which although raised in Cheshire, had already seen service against Prince Rupert at Brentford, under its commander John Brumhall. In Congleton they were joined by another locally raised troop of horse. The total force numbered more than 500 men. Brereton had arrived to organise the local parliamentary sympathisers; he brought with him a case of Drakes (small cannon) and 700 muskets in his baggage train. Most importantly, an experienced Scots professional, Major James Lothian (sometimes spelt LoUthian) came with him, to train recruits for the cadre of a foot regiment of which he was to be colonel.

Brereton sent Major Lothian, Brumhall and about 50 dragoons to occupy Nantwich early on 28th Jan 1643.They got in just ahead of the Royalist commander for this area Sir Thomas Aston, newly arrived from Oxford, who had with him a troop of horse and some companies of Shropshire dragoons. Lothian’s professional skill (it’s presumed) kept them out of the town. As dusk was falling the royalists withdrew eastward down Hospital Street. There, in a narrow lane, they bumped into the remainder of Brereton’s force. In the farcical battle that followed between these two amateur armies, Brereton won. This victory and the skilful defence by Lothian and Co of Nantwich, led to some local squires coming to join Brereton at Nantwich with 2000 followers. From now on till the fall of Chester in 1646, Nantwich became the headquarters of the Cheshire parliamentary party.

At the battle of Middlewich 13th March 1643, Major Lothian marched up Booth Lane from Nantwich with the foot, to attack from the south of Middlewich as Brereton attacked from the west with the cavalry. Aston’s troops who had stood against Brereton now collapsed when the foot attacked from the south, most of Aston’s army fled east, but a large body of men fled into the church. Lothian, however, briskly blew in the main church doors with a petard upon which, the royalists inside surrendered. Col Ellis, Major Gilmore and many Cheshire officers and 0ver 600 soldiers the bulk of them the Cheshire trained band were taken prisoner. A short time after this battle Brereton was made commander of all the Cheshire forces.

Major Lothian continued to train and advise the Cheshire (and Shropshire) forces to be Parliamentarians. He was not heard of again until 17th Dec 1643, a Sunday. When a royalist raid led by Col John Marrow (the commander of the Chester garrison horse) brought the garrison captains of Nantwich rushing from their sermon. Although the raiders were driven off, the invaluable Lothian, who had been left by Brereton (who was elsewhere in the county) as chief military adviser to old Sir George Booth the governor, pursued too far and was captured at Burford. This was a bitter blow in view of the siege of Nantwich by Lord Byron that was about to fall. After the battle of Nantwich, 25th Jan 1644, Major Lothian was exchanged - date unknown.

During the early months of 1645, the Cheshire Roundheads went on the offensive and laid siege to Chester and Beeston Castle. Beeston was effectively cut off, but Chester’s supply line from Wales was still open. On 3rd April 1645, Brereton learnt of a convoy of ammunition from Anglesey was on its way to Chester. He matched into Flintshire to capture it, but the royalist’s hearing of his approach took the convoy into Hawarden castle.

Lothian was left to capture the place by under mining the castle in the hope of securing the good store of ammunition within, as it would be of great use in the siege of Chester. Lothian was at the siege of Hawarden castle, which stood on sandy soil, for several weeks mining the place, which must have caused some problems shoring up the mine. Michael Jones, who was the overall commander of the Cheshire horse, as Lothian was of the Cheshire foot, also watched this side of the River Dee.

At the time of 3rd April we know the following about Lothian and his own regiment only: -

Col James Lothian

Lt Col Gilbert Gerrard of Crewwood Cheshire Esq.

A report by Brereton to Parliament at the end of May reported that the siege along with those of Chester and Beeston was progressing well, and that he had high hopes as long as there was no outside Royalist aid. Unbeknown to him Charles 1 was on his way. The sieges continued until the king was at Market Drayton. The Roundheads in the area around Cheshire and Shropshire now manned their garrisons, awaiting the storm that must follow and Brereton, with his remaining troops, withdrew behind the Mersey River. But Charles turned towards Leicester and his subsequent defeat at Naseby 14th June. Brereton now reinvested Beeston Castle and concentrated on the outright besieging of Chester. At this point, Brereton had again to return to Parliament to get his commission extended because of the self-denying ordinance. Whilst he was away, the Siege of Chester was taken over by the local committee.

The foot was commanded overall by Col Lothian and the horse overall by Col Michael Jones.

On 20th Sept 1645, Lothian and Jones sent a forlorn hope against Chester’s outworks they got over the walls and opened the gates. The Parliament forces now poured in, though the royalists managed to set fire to the bulk of the buildings, after a bitter fight, the outworks and suburbs were captured.

It was only by the narrowest of margins that the parliament soldiers failed to get through one of the city wall gates. News now arrived that the king was on his way but his whereabouts was unknown. On the 22nd September, a breech was made in Chester’s East Wall, but a storming party failed to exploit this. At this point Charles was only at Chirk Castle, and his army was on its way to the relief of Chester. Late on 23rd Sept he arrived in Chester. On 24th September, the battle of Rowton Moor was fought, between the cavalry of the royalist Langdale and parliaments cavalry under Poyntz. Jones with Col Booth now went to the aid of Poyntz, whilst Lothian held Chester’s suburbs against any aid from the royalists inside Chester, trying to come to Langdale’s aid. At this point, just prior to the city’s royalists starting to come out of the North gate, Charles had been watching the start of the battle from the top of the cathedral tower. When a cannon shot from one of the siege guns fired at Charles and took the head off the officer standing next to him, who was at the time pointing things out to him. Charles now retired to watch the remainder of the battle from the phoenix tower.

In the royalist defeat that now followed, the parliamentarian troops in the suburbs did great execution on the royalists fleeing into the city. With Lothian’s guard inflicting heavy losses against royalists trapped against the city wall. A few days later, Lothian and Jones borrowed experienced troops from the siege of Chester, who could only be spared for a very short duration, as their position was temporarily filled by inexperienced auxiliary troops until their return was secured. Lothian and Jones arranged to meet with Gen. Mytton, along with troops from Wem and Oswestry. Together, they attacked Col Vaughan at Denbigh, who was arranging a relieving force for Chester, before his army was at full strength. Brereton now arrived from London with his commission extended (like Cromwell) gave his agreement to his officers. The battle of Denbigh Green was a decisive win for Mytton. Lothian and Jones now returned back to the siege of Chester as quickly as possible.

The next reference to Lothian by name is in 1648 when Hamilton invaded England. Cheshire started to raise three foot regiments. Each to be 600 strong, the commanders to be Col Lothian, Col Massey, and Col Croxton, under the over all command of Col Duckenfield, military governor of Chester. After Hamilton’s defeat at Preston, Lothian’s regiment (that took no part) was dispatched to assist Major-General Mytton in suppressing the rising in N-Wales

The fact that Lothian a professional Scots Soldier turned Cheshire Land owner. Would be fighting against his compatriots did not seem to worry the government, as the most notable of the covenanting generals had refused to take the "Engagement".

Whilst with Major-General Mytton, Col Lothian and his regiment fought at the battle of Beaumaris, 1st Oct 1648, at 3pm. Lothian’s regiment being given the task of taking the church.

Reference to Lothian and his regiment, is given in an account of the battle by the schoolmaster Williams as follows:

"Major Pennant (R) and his troop of horse charged the enemy, in the lane coming down from the park towards Mr Richard Vaughan’s house, and was like to take Col Lothian prisoner. Captain Lloyd of Penhwnllys (R) having guard of the church. Did lock his men in, and ran away with the key. (until his dyeing day was ever after known as Capt. church) These men firing from the steeple and leads and some others firing from Court Mawr garden. Played very hotly upon the enemy and killed several especially Capt. Hancock of Col Lothian’s regiment his Lieutenant and Ensign in the clay pits and back lanes".

It was said of the Anglesey Islanders, that they were so full of disorder and confusion in the fight as to be easily routed, and the battle was an affray or a scuffle. If that was the case, they did well to "SCUFFLE" for well over two hours. Col Lothian appears to have come across one of the strongest defended positions at Beaumaris.

Parliament lost 40 men killed and many sore wounded. Royalists lost 30 men killed and over 400 prisoners. No mention is made of Col James Lothian in the 1651 invasion of England, in fact, he is not heard of again.

Yours in the cause

Garry Scott, Ensign. Crawfords.


At the battle of Rowton Moor some accounts say it was Jones and Adjutant-General Lothian that went to Poyntz’s aid, and not Jones and Booth.

On 20th June 1643, some of the Nantwich horse and dragoons to Hamner (Nr Wrexham) believing the royalists to have ammunition hidden there. They were ambushed there by the royalists and routed. Among the parliament prisoners taken was a Scots Lieutenant-Colonel FLAGGE or FLACK.

Nothing is heard of him again. Nor have I found anything else about him as yet.

There are gaps in the history of Col James Lothian but I hope when I get more time, I can fill these gaps in.
Main books used for reference were

Author Garry Scott, Loudoun's Regt.

Return to Top

©2007-2011 ScotWars All Rights Reserved. [Disclaimer]
Site designed & compiled by....
Rab Taylor
Webmaster of PUBCAT  RomanScotland